IdeaWins: Apprentice the Microsoft Way
Business, Marketing / PR, SMB / SME, Startups December 12th, 2006
I’ve previously covered Microsoft’s Contest for Innovative Small Business Idea: basically a promotion for the new MS Office Accounting 2007 package, dressed up as a contest. Still, it’s an opportunity for entrepreneurs, especially those in retail.
Originally MS released the site in a rush and not all components were ready, so submissions were only by emailing a downloadable form. They’ve fixed it now, so here’s the new fancy interactive submission page.
Microsoft also picked “celebrity” judges, lead by Carolyn Kepcher of ex-Apprentice fame. Now, here’s my challenge: try to find this information on the IdeaWins site
. I couldn’t.
Why hire “stars” (just how much of a star she will be without The Donald is still to be seen…), and “hide” the fact? I only know about it from an email by MS PR - or so I think, it came from a gmail (sic!) account. The press release calls Carolyn’s appointment an “unprecedented move to galvanize the imagination of millions of Americans”. Hm… I don’t know about galvanizing… perhaps I’d feel galvanized by the end of the video, but I admit I did not watch it all the way. Why? Because I generally prefer knowing what I am getting into upfront. In my previous post I stated:
”the FAQ is actually all about the Accounting package, and the contest terms are somewhat hard to find.”
Now it got worse. There is a contest-related FAQ - well-hidden, unless you use my direct link. The real catch: this is only available from inside the interactive signup, *after* you have chosen the high-bandwidth option. If you picked low-bandwidth, you’re out of luck - and info.
. A “good” example of bad design getting in the way of creativity. Which is quite typical of The Microsoft Way. ![]()

Zoli Erdos

Dear Zoli Erdos,
Thank you so very much for your blog in re; to ideawins sponsored by Microsoft…yeah, I was having a terrible time finding out any information…did manage to to do the submission using broadband…downloading the form didn’t work at all, as I wasn’t certain that my submission made it through, so I tried to download the form this morning and could not…so glad I typed ideawins in my address bar and found your blog…thank you for being so kind to all of us entrepreneurs out there…you were a huge help!…cremaurer@comcast.net