After repeatedly crying out for a solution, I was really happy to become a beta user for coComment. Little did I know that there were actually TWO comment tracking solutions announced almost the simultaneously.
The coComment launch was a masterpiece of viral marketing: all it took was a couple of A-list bloggers (Michael Arrington, Robert Scoble, Dave Winer, Om Malik, Steve Gillmor, Cory Doctorow, Richard MacManus, Stowe Boyd, and others) and a wildfire started. Of course it did not hurt that coComment addressed a real burning need. Or was it the 109–yr-old Cognac the Raclette and the jacuzzi? More on the launch by Don Dodge.
The other announcement, that of myComments, although it happened a few days earlier, went almost unnoticed. No wonder, Diego, the author announced it on his own not-so-widely read blog. A lesson to learn in marketing.
I have not had a chance to try myComments, so my initial comparison is based on what I read on his site, and some email information from Diego.
Both products essentially do the same: if I leave a comment on someone’s blog, I can receive an RSS feed of all subsequent comments – the full conversation. They have a fundamentally different approach getting there though:
CoComment requires a bookmarklet or a FireFox extension, and I have to click once to activate coCo before posting my message.
MyComments on the other hand requires a plug-in to be installed in the blog where I go to comment. If the plug-in is present, I don’t have to click anymore. At first glance this appears to be more convenient, since no extra step is required before posting the comment. There is a problem, however – this is a great concept once it is widely used, but how do we get to that scale? I want the results, but I can’t do anything about it, I am dependent on the host blog having the plug-in. We’ll have to see if this solution can take off – until then, it’s coCo-time.
Related posts:
- coComment: Comment Tracking
- At last, a way to track blog comments
- CoComment and the Conversation Index
- CoComment: semantically forked conversation?
- Testing out coComment
- coComment – Tracking Blog Comments
- Time spent in signal
- Coco nuts, invitation code has been already used
- Comment Tracking with coComment
Update (2/6): Here’s a comparison of the two services, and a comprehensive review of blog commenting in general.
Update 2 (2/16): Apparently there is a better solution, see here.
Tags: Blogs, Blogging, Blogosphere, Conversation, Blog Comments, Comment Tracking, Conversational Index, Tracking, coComment, myComments
Recent Comments