Will Google Pull a Plaxo?

Google Operating System speculates that Gmail will soon display status updates from your contacts:

It’s not very clear what kind of updates you will receive, but they’re probably the latest important actions of your contacts from different Google services.

Ionut says based on reading some Google code that users will be able to delete updates – now word whether there will be a “Big Switch” to opt out globally. The functionality itself would be closer to Facebook’s newsfeed, the reason I am comparing it to Plaxo is that Plaxo became a metaphor for spam in its early years, and it is back at it now, with all the unwanted Plaxo Pulse notifications.

The contact updates, especially if it’s not easy to opt-out once and for all would be nothing but spam. What makes it even worse is that Gmail Contacts are really not contacts: anybody you answer automatically gets added to your Address Book, whether you like it or not. And guess what: there is no way to turn this off. (In fact, in the new version of Gmail -not yet available for Google Apps accounts- you can’t even delete more than 20 contacts at any given time.)

I really hope it does not happen. Gmail is the Crown Jewel of Google services, and as such, more productivity-oriented for most of us, then say Orkut or Picasa are. They can’t seriously think of clobbering the screen with garbage like that. Can they? smile_sad


  1. if it is something that demands my attention, i will drop the service..

  2. Could be a welcome addition says

    I’m sick of rewriting everyones new cell phone #, new email address, etc. I’d love to have people’s new contact info automatically updated. Please no email reminders of birthdays google, but if it’s running in the background and I can send an email with more confidence that it’s going to get to the person, great!

  3. Zoli,

    Sorry have to disagree with you about Plaxo. Unfair.

    Early on sure. But now they offer quite a granularity in the choices you have for what emails you receive. True you have to understand that the options are there and it isn’t very intuitive about how to get there. But, I think Pulse is pretty powerful and I am willing to have some trade-offs. Plus I have to admit I actually like the birthday notices – I am really bad at remembering dates. But I wish they could let me choose to only have certain birthdays like friends.

  4. Jonathan,

    You like it, you use it. I don’t want it, so why do I have to sign up (or just log in?? since I am using the original Plaxo..) and figure out how to shut off these notifications? Auto-including me is spam.

  5. Fair enough. The default should be set to have the notifications turned off.


  1. […] actual friends. He compares the potential fiasco that would be involved to Plaxo’s notorious spam approach in its early days, but I think he may be overreacting. For one thing, you can choose to show only […]

  2. […] fact, something I had hoped Google would do for quite some time. I don’t share the fear that some seem to have – that it’ll become an overbearing spammy nuisence. I do, however, see this road to a […]

  3. […] matter if you are @scobleizerLouis Gray on Size doesn’t matter if you are @scobleizerWill Google Pull a Plaxo?| Zoli’s Blog on Google should be carefulJoy on Who or What is Rgergerger?Frederic on Just some […]

  4. […] Web activity from our friends. Sure, they have to opt-in, but it’s better than auto­mat­ically spamming people with updates from everyone they’ve ever emailed (even once). Unrequested sharing of items in […]

%d bloggers like this: